Star Trek Voyager – The Complete Second Season
June 30, 2010Cheap Star Trek Voyager – The Complete Second Season Review
It’s fitting that this season has an episode in which Voyager is duplicated, as this season demonstrated, perhaps better than any other, just how good or bad the show could be from episode to episode, especially in the early years.
Limiting my comments to just a few representative episodes: Voyager Season 2 has the much-maligned “Threshold” and the awful “The Thaw.” These are truly Voyager at its worst: bad ideas, poorly executed. “Threshold” could have been good, as it begins with an interesting premise, but the show degenerates into sheer stupidity. Along with it, “The Thaw” starts lamely and stays that way throughout. These two are best put aside and forgotten.
On the other hand, the season closes with a very strong set of episodes. “Tuvix” explores an interesting idea and, though it could have been improved in some ways, nevertheless builds to a kind of morally ambiguous conclusion that is rarely seen in this series. Like the doctor, I don’t agree with Captain Janeway’s final decision, but I very much enjoyed watching her deal with it. If only these emotions had carried through to future episodes, there could have been some interesting ramifications.
“Resolutions” is an interesting exploration of Janeway and Chakotay’s relationship, and asks the question of whether desperately trying to return home has been the right choice for them and the Voyager crew. Again in this episode, the conclusion is bittersweet, and I think the show is all the better for it.
And the season finale, “Basics, Part I,” has a great conflict and genuine tension. The return of a nasty villain and the Voyager crew in a real predicament with a cliffhanger ending is the perfect formula to close out the season.
When Voyager first aired, I was frustrated by its weaknesses more than I am now. To my pleasant surprise, I think Voyager has aged rather well. Though the season begins somewhat weakly, and the “Threshold” and “The Thaw” episodes are terrible, there’s much to enjoy. There are better seasons than this, but it’s certainly worthwhile viewing, and I’m sure the finale will have you rushing to start on season 3.












